Written by

Where's the frame

Maribelle Bierens

February 5, 2024 5:56 PM

GMT

More and more, the concept of reality has become increasingly elusive. Do we ever know when wer're looking at images, listingen to music, or reading text whether it's original or not? Representations or copies of reality have become so pervasive that they often replace the original reality itself. Against this backdrop of uncertainty, Night Café is thrilled to announce 'in the coulisse,' a duo-exhibition showcasing the works of Ilê Sartuzi and Lucy Neish in which they explore the complexities of representation, inviting viewers to question the very nature of perception and reality.

Installation view ‘in the coulisse’. From left to right: Ilê Sartuzi, Curtain, 2023. 123 x 219 x 21 cm. Velvet and pins on wooden board; AD MR, 2024. 32 x 32 cm. Oil on linen and aluminium special frame; no drama, 2021-2024. Vinyl on wall; Lucy Neish, I had done it solely to avoid looking a fool, 16.5 x11.5 cm, oil on canvas, 2023; Kendal’s Foal, 16.5 x11.5 cm, oil on canvas, 2023; Debilitating Nostalgia, 16.5 x11.5 cm, oil on canvas, 2023; For the Yellow smoke II, 16.5 x11.5 cm, oil on canvas, 2023 

Ever since the second half of the twentieth century, art history has undergone an undeniable and substantial shift in the realm of perception and representation. The postmodern way of thinking, asserting that reality is subjective and constructed, has deeply influenced artistic approaches of reality, leading to a questioning of grand narratives and universal truths and fostering skepticism toward traditional notions of authenticity. 

Often, when viewing art, we are exposed to simulated representations of reality. Through the push and pull from registers of apparently genuine, the works transport the viewers between what is present and mediated, between memory and the actual, and between the theatrical and the mundane. By doing so, ‘in the coulise’ explores not only what images can show but also what is beyond the limits of the pictorial representations, playing with illusions, what is out-of-frame, behind the curtains, and in the wings of the theatre. 

Installation view ‘in the coulisse’ left to right: Ilê Sartuzi, Untitled, 2023, velvet and pins on wooden board, 37 x 29 cm; no drama, 2021-2024, vinyl on wall, variable dimensions; Fantasma, 2023, gelatin silver print, 60 × 60 cm; Lucy Neish, 35 Weeks, 2024. Graphite on Paper.

Through a process of gathering and matching, Lucy Neish creates filmic collections of paintings that take subjects out of context playing with how they are read. Drawing on screenshots of films, inadvertent pictures from nightclubs, or poached images from WhatsApp groups. They are not just captured scenes but tiny portals to personal or created memories — yours, mine, and hers. For the viewer the source of the image is left unclear, destabilising a sense of permanence and obscuring place and time. 

Her paintings render accurate representations of nature, fur, or the haze of a screenshot. As they encounter the rough texture of the canvas, (knobbled by the remnants of past paintings) they juxtapose the topology of the support. Her faithful systems of representation in painting are in contrast with the very reality of the material quality of the canvas.

Lucy Neish, 35 Weeks, 2024. Graphite on Paper. 

35 Weeks (2024), portrays an open window where the curtain, caught by the wind, bulges out of the frame. While it’s based on a picture Neish has taken herself, viewers are left uncertain whether it's a scene from a movie, a glimpse of a personal moment, or a photograph shared by someone else. The image is ambiguous but there is a certain specificity that lends itself to transport the viewer to a curated time and place.

For the Yellow smoke II (2023), which pictures two disco balls on the ceiling of a club, is part of a series of work that regurgitates minutely similar works based on the same absent-mindedly taken photo. One photo from one night has taken on new weight as it is reused, allowing it to become something else – a casual image injected with a certain gravity. Neish solidifies transient moments, wherever they come from. 

Lucy Neish, For the Yellow smoke II, 16.5 x11.5 cm, oil on canvas, 2023 

While these paintings operate on an intimate and personal level, like a portal to another dimension, Ilê Sartuzi’s work plays with that idea in a slightly different way. A large red velvet curtain sculpture (Curtain, 2023) is pinned shut. If there were – at any point in time – a possibility of a passage through this, now it seems to be closed off. On a spatial level, however, the curtain could suggest another space behind the white wall. Yet in reality, such a space does not exist. There is nothing behind to reveal and nothing to hide. This dry and direct reading could be contradicted if we say that the painting (AD MR, 2023) and the gelatin silver print (phantom, 2023) are playing exactly with the uncertainty of what really is behind these fabric folds.

Ilê Sartuzi, Curtain, 2023. Velvet and pins on wooden board, 123 x 219 x 21 cm.

On a different level, in No Drama (2021-2024), Sartuzi playfully pokes fun at the very idea of drama. The dry text referring to a popular song from the 2000s could be read as singing. The repetition of the negation creates rhythm, and the simple gesture goes against the dramaticism that is represented in the exhibition. This work could be seen as a synthesis between the theatricality – without being necessarily dramatic – and minimal and precise formal procedures in Sartuzi’s work.

Installation view ‘in the coulisse’ from left to right Ilê Sartuzi, AD MR, 2024. 32 x 32 cm. Oil on linen and aluminium special frame; no drama, 2021-2024. Vinyl on wall; Lucy Neish, I had done it solely to avoid looking a fool, 16.5 x11.5 cm, oil on canvas, 2023; Kendal’s Foal, 16.5 x11.5 cm, oil on canvas, 2023; Debilitating Nostalgia, 16.5 x11.5 cm, oil on canvas, 2023; For the Yellow smoke II, 16.5 x11.5 cm, oil on canvas, 2023

In a world where the simulacra seem to be the new rule, to trace back unmediated encounters with the “real” is an uphill battle. What Ilê Sartuzi and Lucy Neish are proposing is to investigate – in the cracks of representation – what is behind the grain (or the pixel) of the image and how all this ultimately are embodied with matter in space. And what if we don’t know?

The exhibition will open on January 24 and run until February 22 at Night Café, 162 New Cavendish Street in Fitzrovia, London. For more information visit Night Café's website.

Suggested reading: